, Special report No 3/90 on ECSC, Euratom and NCI loans and borrowings of the Communities…

In forcesince 10 May 1990

4.4 The Commission shares the Court's view that interest subsidies have a special attraction given the average cost of loans granted to beneficiaries. However, it would point out that the competitiveness of the Commission's loans in general is demonstrated by the fact that many firms in various Member States have had recourse to loans - both direct and global - which were largely unsubsidized.

The Commission wishes to qualify the claims of some clients that they were able to obtain better conditions 'elsewhere`. These must be exceptional cases where Member States offer loans as part of national aid measures on terms which do not match those ruling on the market.

4.5 4.6 As the Commission has indicated in its reply to the Annual Report, it has already tightened up checks on the reliability of total cost price calculations and devised a standard method to be applied to these calculations.

4.7 On the question of the margin charged on global loans by financial intermediaries, the Commission would stress that in this context, it is quite normal for financial institutions to receive payment for the work they have to carry out and to cover themselves against the risk of final beneficiaries defaulting on loans. The Commission feels that the rate it sets is quite acceptable.

As regards the ECSC margin imposed by the Commisson, the method of calculation used is laid down in the internal rules. This margin has now been reduced and reflects the real costs borne by the Commission. It is only applied when loan contracts do not contain an indemnity clause covering all the risks assumed by the ECSC. When such a clause exists and when the intervention of a national agent is not required, the Commission does not include any margin and the rate of on-lending corresponds exactly to the actual costs of the funds raised.

In the past, the inclusion of a margin in the cost of loans was necessary to constitute a reserve in the ECSC balance sheet large enough to give lenders every assurance and thus secure for the ECSC the highest possible rating - a vital element in raising capital at the lowest cost. The size of the margin applied to loans was justified by a high-risk factor particularly during the most crucial phase of the restructuring of the coal and steel industry. The margin has been reduced in line with the general decrease in risk due in particular to the improvement in the industry's financial situation.