The safety level provided by the technical specifications in EN 81-1 and by the M33v3 lift can only be compared by assessing the same scenario in a lift compliant with EN 81-1 and in the M33v3 lift. This means that, as explained above, the only scenario to be considered when assessing the risk of crushing is the case in which the brake fails in both lifts. Based on the evidence provided by Orona to the German authority before the adoption of the measure, and in particular the letter from Liftinstituut to Orona of 21 April 2015, if the brake fails, the speed of the free acceleration of only few meters would already imply that the travel speed of the lift would, for both lifts, make it impossible for the buffers to stop the lift car and would likely cause the buffers to collapse. In that event, the car would hit the ceiling of the well and crush anyone on the car roof independently of the vertical distance available. As explained by Liftinstituut in its letter, if the brake fails, there is a risk of crushing in both lifts, as the probability that the refuge space could avoid an accident is very small irrespective of the time it takes to assume a certain position on the car roof. In this respect, the German authority stated in its email to the Commission of 28 May 2019, that when the brake fails, neither the M33v3 lift nor a lift compliant with EN 81-1 can be stopped and a possible failure of the buffers is equally probable for both lifts.
56 3. ASSESSMENT, Decision_act (EU) 2021/534
In forcesince 24 Mar 2021cited 1×
Arrêt du Tribunal (troisième chambre) du 13 septembre 2023. République fédérale d'Allemagne contre Commission européenne.Decision
En tout état de cause, il y a lieu de constater que, aux considérants 51 à 56 de la décision attaquée, alors qu’elle n’y était pas tenue, la Commission a néanmoins examiné les causes potentielles d’un incident dans …
13 Sep 2023 · 62021TJ0349