As regards the time aspect, Orona stated that, as described in the technical file, the car roof of the M33v3 lift is flat and free from obstacles, and that due to this fact maintenance personnel may assume a safe position faster by lying flat on the roof. Orona pointed out in particular that on a car roof of a lift complying with EN 81-1, there can be many components interfering in the space for the lying position, for example ropes and their attachments, which can delay the time to assume the safe lying position. Furthermore, Orona emphasised that EN 81-1 only states that the safety space must be reachable from the working space. However, in the M33v3 lift, the working space coincides with the safety space, meaning that if something goes wrong and a person must adopt the lying position, the person is already in the correct place, which reduces the time needed to assume the safe position. The differences in the technical specifications (namely the obstacles on the car roof and the access to the safety space) between the M33v3 lift and a lift compliant with EN 81-1 were further clarified in Orona’s letter to the Commission of 20 January 2016 and in its email to the Commission of 12 July 2019.
30 2. POSITIONS AND ARGUMENTS OF THE PARTIES › 2.2. Position and arguments of Orona, Decision_act (EU) 2021/534
In forcesince 24 Mar 2021