29 2. POSITIONS AND ARGUMENTS OF THE PARTIES › 2.2. Position and arguments of Orona, Decision_act (EU) 2021/534

In forcesince 24 Mar 2021

Orona stated in its observations of 18 May 2016 that in the national measure, the German authority argues that it would take ‘considerably more time’ for a technician on the roof of the car to assume the lying position, which is required to ensure safety in the lift, in contrast to the crouching position. Orona states that this claim was unsubstantiated by any evidence submitted by the German authority and that the need to assume a safe position is not a specific requirement under Directive 95/16/EC. Furthermore, following a meeting between the German authority and Orona on 15 December 2015, it was agreed, in line with the national measure, that Orona would perform some additional trials to further support the safe design of the M33v3 lift. Special emphasis was placed on the influence of the size of the lift roof on reaction time. In this respect, the IK4-Ikerlan study found that the position of the maintenance personnel and the size of the M33v3 lifts is not a factor influencing reaction time. In addition, it is shown that age and body mass index have no effect on the reaction time. Furthermore, the IK4-Ikerlan study concluded that the fact that the reaction time for taking up the squatting position in lifts according to EN 81-20 was on average only 1,26 seconds does not affect the specific potential risk, since this time difference corresponds to a mere 0,9 m with an inspection speed of 0,6 m/s. The different reaction times could be relevant only in the event of a failure of the safety system, for example the redundant brake system. However, in that scenario, the difference in height would not matter, as an accident would be fatal in both the M33v3 lift and a lift meeting the harmonised standards.

  • celex=31995L0016
  • num:eu=1995/16