On the other hand, in cases where the Spanish acquiring company did not hold the rights directly or indirectly until after 21 December 2007, any incompatible aid will be recovered from this beneficiary unless, firstly, before 21 December 2007 an irrevocable obligation was entered into by a Spanish acquiring company to hold such rights; secondly, the contract contained a suspensive condition linked to the fact that the operation at issue is subject to the mandatory approval of a regulatory authority and, thirdly, the operation had been notified before 21 December 2007. In fact, after the publication of the initiating Decision in the Official Journal, it cannot be argued that a prudent trader could not have foreseen the adoption of a Community measure that could affect his interests like the present Decision. In the light of the above, the Commission concludes that the recovery shall take place with respect to all cases not covered by recitals 167 and 169 of this Decision. The Commission also considers that the measure at issue does not constitute aid if, at the time the beneficiaries enjoyed its benefits, all the conditions laid down in legislation adopted pursuant to Article 2 of Regulation (EC) No 994/98 and applicable at the time the tax deduction was enjoyed were met.
170 VI. ASSESSMENT OF THE SCHEME › G. Recovery of the aid, Decision_act (EU) 2011/5
Arrêt du Tribunal (huitième chambre) du 27 septembre 2023. Telefónica SA et Iberdrola, SA contre Commission européenne.Decision
À cet égard, il est manifeste, au contraire, que les décisions initiales contiennent de nombreuses références explicites aux prises de participations indirectes. Celles-ci sont ainsi expressément visées dans les parties contenant la …
27 Sep 2023 · 62015TJ0256
Judgment of the General Court (Eighth Chamber) of 27 September 2023. Banco Santander, SA and Others v European Commission.Decision
On the contrary, it is clear that the initial decisions contain numerous explicit references to indirect acquisitions. Indirect acquisitions are explicitly referred to in the detailed description of the scheme set up by Article 12(5) of …
27 Sep 2023 · 62015TJ0012
Arrêt du Tribunal (huitième chambre) du 27 septembre 2023. Ferrovial, SA e.a. contre Commission européenne.Decision
À cet égard, il est manifeste, au contraire, que les décisions initiales contiennent de nombreuses références explicites aux prises de participations indirectes. Celles-ci sont ainsi expressément visées dans les parties contenant la …
27 Sep 2023 · 62015TJ0252
Arrêt du Tribunal (huitième chambre) du 27 septembre 2023. Sociedad General de Aguas de Barcelona, SA contre Commission européenne.Decision
À cet égard, il est manifeste, au contraire, que les décisions initiales contiennent de nombreuses références explicites aux prises de participations indirectes. Celles-ci sont ainsi expressément visées dans les parties contenant la …
27 Sep 2023 · 62015TJ0253
Arrêt du Tribunal (huitième chambre) du 27 septembre 2023. Royaume d'Espagne contre Commission européenne.Decision
À cet égard, il est manifeste, au contraire, que les décisions initiales contiennent de nombreuses références explicites aux prises de participations indirectes. Celles-ci sont ainsi expressément visées dans les parties contenant la …
27 Sep 2023 · 62014TJ0826
Judgment of the Court (Eighth Chamber) of 26 June 2025. European Commission v Kingdom of Spain and Others.Decision
In the present case, it is expressly stated in Article 1(2) and recitals 167, 170 and 175 of Decision 2011/5, and in Article 1(2) and (4) and recital 210 of Decision 2011/282, that the exceptions to the cessation and recovery obligations …
26 Jun 2025 · 62023CJ0776
- celex=31998R0994