44 IV. COMMENTS FROM THE SPANISH AUTHORITIES AND INTERESTED THIRD PARTIES › A. Comments from the Spanish authorities and the 30 interested parties › A.1. The measure at issue does not constitute State aid › A.1.2. The measure at issue does not favour certain undertakings or production, Decision_act (EU) 2011/5

In forcesince 28 Oct 2009

Firstly, Spain maintains that Article 12(5) TRLIS is a general measure since it is open to any Spanish company whatever its activity, sector, size, form or other characteristics. The only condition for the taxpayer to be able to benefit from the measure at issue is to be tax resident in Spain. The fact that not all taxpayers benefit from the measure in question does not make it selective. Therefore, Article 12(5) TRLIS is neither de facto nor de jure selective within the meaning of Article 87(1) of the Treaty. Accordingly, by letter dated 14 July 2008 [See recital 12.], the Spanish authorities provided data extracted from the 2006 Spanish tax returns which show that all types of companies (SMEs and large undertakings), as well as companies active in different economic sectors, had benefited from the measure at issue. The Spanish authorities also stress that in a recent judgment [See the judgment of the Court of First Instance in Case T-233/04 Netherlands v Commission [2008] ECR, II-591.], the Court of First Instance indicated that a limited number of beneficiaries is not sufficient in itself to establish the selectivity of the measure since that group can actually represent all of the undertakings in a particular legal and factual situation. In particular, the Spanish authorities stress that the measure at issue bears similarities with a recent case [See the Commission Decision of 14 February 2008, N 480/07, Reduction in revenue from certain intangible assets (OJ C 80, 1.4.2008, p. 1).] that the Commission considered to be a general measure and they therefore request the same treatment.

  • Judgment of the Court of First Instance (Fifth Chamber, extended composition) of 10 April 2008. Kingdom of the Netherlands v Commission of tDecision

    10 Apr 2008 · 62004TJ0233

  • Treaty establishing the European Community87Law

  • case:eu=T-233/92