48 IV. COMMENTS FROM THE SPANISH AUTHORITIES AND INTERESTED THIRD PARTIES › A. Comments from the Spanish authorities and the 30 interested parties › A.1. The measure at issue does not constitute State aid › A.1.2. The measure at issue does not favour certain undertakings or production, Decision_act (EU) 2011/5

In forcesince 28 Oct 2009cited 2×

Fourthly, the introduction of the measure at issue is in any case justified by the principle of neutrality, which underlies all Spanish tax legislation. This principle implies that the tax treatment of an investment should be neutral irrespective of the instruments used, whether transfer of assets, business combination or share acquisition. Therefore, the tax amortisation of an investment should be identical whatever the instrument used to carry out the acquisition in question. The final aim of the measure at issue, in this broader perspective, is to ensure the free movement of capital by avoiding discriminatory tax treatment between transactions with target companies and purely domestic transactions. Given that acquisitions of significant shareholdings in domestic companies could lead to a business combination of the acquiring and the acquired companies with no legal or fiscal barriers, the goodwill that would ensue for tax purposes as a result of the combination could be amortised [Pursuant to Article 89(3) TRLIS.]. However, goodwill of cross-border operations cannot arise because harmonisation at Community level is not complete or — even worse — because there is no harmonisation outside the Community. According to the Spanish authorities [See the Spanish authorities’ letter of 5 December 2007 to the Commission, p. 35, as referred to in recital 7.], the Spanish tax system provides for different tax schemes, as in the case of shareholding acquisitions in foreign companies compared with acquisitions in Spanish companies (impossible to undertake merger operations, risk assumption, etc.), in order to achieve the tax neutrality sought by the Spanish domestic legislation and Community law itself and also in order to ensure that the Spanish tax system is consistent and efficient. Although Council Directive 90/434/EEC of 23 July 1990 on the common system of taxation applicable to mergers, divisions, transfers of assets and exchanges of shares concerning companies of different Member States [OJ L 225, 20.8.1990, p. 1.] (hereinafter the Cross-border Taxation Directive) has removed tax barriers, Directive 2005/56/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 26 October 2005 on cross-border mergers of limited liability companies [OJ L 310, 25.11.2005, p. 1.] (hereinafter the Cross-border Mergers Directive) [The comments from the Spanish authorities were received on 5 December 2007 whereas the Member States had to apply Directive 2005/56/EC by 15 December 2007.] has not yet been transposed into national law. In practice, this situation makes business combinations between companies from different Member States impossible. Therefore, the aim of the measure at issue is to remove the negative impact of these barriers, for whose existence Spain is not answerable [See the recitals to Council Regulation (EC) No 1435/2003 of 22 July 2003 on the Statute for a European Cooperative Society (SCE) (OJ L 207, 18.8.2003, p. 1), and the opinion of the Economic and Social Committee of 28 April 2004, COM(2003) 703 final — 2003/2077(COD).]. Consequently, limiting the scope of the measure at issue to cross-border acquisitions is necessary to enforce the neutrality principle. In this way, still according to the Spanish authorities, the Spanish tax system treats differently taxpayers who are in different situations [As stated on page 8 of the Spanish authorities’ letter of 30 June 2008 — see recital 9 above.], thereby ensuring that the Spanish tax system is neutral as required by the Spanish tax system itself and the Treaty. In particular, on 16 June 2009 the Spanish authorities acknowledged that although the Cross-border Mergers Directive had a positive impact, European companies would still face a number of obstacles [With reference to the Commission’s assessment of the implementation of Directive 2004/25/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 21 April 2004 on takeover bids (OJ L 142, 30.4.2004, p. 12).] to cross-border mergers because of non-harmonisation of national legislation (rights of minority shareholders, rights of creditors, trademark issues, wider regulatory aspects including labour law, general political and strategic considerations).

  • Judgment of the General Court (Ninth Chamber, Extended Composition) of 15 November 2018. World Duty Free Group, SA, formerly Autogrill EspañDecision

    Secondly, in its observations which are set out in the contested decision, the Kingdom of Spain stated that the measure at issue had been adopted as a result of the fact that obstacles, in particular legal ones, existed, which prevented …

    15 Nov 2018 · 62010TJ0219(01)

  • Arrêt du Tribunal (neuvième chambre) du 15 novembre 2018. Banco Santander, SA contre Commission européenne.Decision

    Deuxièmement, dans ses observations exposées dans la décision attaquée, le Royaume d’Espagne a indiqué que la mesure litigieuse avait été adoptée en raison du fait qu’il existerait des obstacles, notamment juridiques, …

    15 Nov 2018 · 62010TJ0227