Secondly, according to the Spanish authorities and the 30 interested parties, in its initiating Decision the Commission mixed up the concept of selectivity and the objective conditions of the measure at issue which refer only to certain transactions (i.e. shareholding in a foreign target company). Indeed, the Commission alleges that Article 12(5) TRLIS is selective since the same treatment is not granted to comparable investments in Spanish companies. However, the Commission fails to recognise that the selectivity criterion is not determined by the fact that the beneficiary of the measure at issue is a group of companies or a multinational company that has a share in a target company. The fact that a measure benefits only companies that comply with the objective criterion laid down in the measure at issue does not in itself make it selective. The selectivity criterion implies that subjective restrictions should be imposed on the beneficiary of the measure at issue. The selectivity criterion created for this procedure is inconsistent with previous Commission practice and too vague and broad. Taking this concept further would lead to the erroneous conclusion that most tax deductible expenses fall within the scope of Article 87(1) of the Treaty.
45 IV. COMMENTS FROM THE SPANISH AUTHORITIES AND INTERESTED THIRD PARTIES › A. Comments from the Spanish authorities and the 30 interested parties › A.1. The measure at issue does not constitute State aid › A.1.2. The measure at issue does not favour certain undertakings or production, Decision_act (EU) 2011/5
In forcesince 28 Oct 2009