Fourthly, the Commission incorrectly refers to Articles 11(4) and 89(3) TRLIS to establish the existence of an advantage. In the initiating Decision, the Commission states that neither a business combination nor takeover of the target company is necessary to benefit from Article 12(5) TRLIS. This statement reflects a misunderstanding of the Spanish tax system since these two Articles do not prevent a group of companies that jointly acquires control of a target company from deducting a corresponding fraction of the goodwill resulting from the operation. Hence, application of these two Articles does not require individual control of the target company in order to benefit from the measure at issue. In this context, it would be inappropriate to consider that Article 12(5) TRLIS offers more favourable treatment than Articles 11(4) or 89(3) TRLIS as regards the controlling position of the beneficiaries. Finally, it should be noted that the 5 % shareholding criterion is consistent with the conditions laid down in Article 89(3) TRLIS and also with Commission guidelines and practice [See the Commission Decision of 22 September 2004, N 354/04, Irish Company Holding Regime (OJ C 131, 28.5.2005, p. 10).].
40 IV. COMMENTS FROM THE SPANISH AUTHORITIES AND INTERESTED THIRD PARTIES › A. Comments from the Spanish authorities and the 30 interested parties › A.1. The measure at issue does not constitute State aid › A.1.1. The measure at issue does not confer an economic advantage, Decision_act (EU) 2011/5
In forcesince 28 Oct 2009