167 VI. ASSESSMENT OF THE SCHEME › G. Recovery of the aid, Decision_act (EU) 2011/5

In forcesince 28 Oct 2009cited 9×

Accordingly, the Commission concludes that the beneficiaries of the contested measure had a legitimate expectation that the aid would not be recovered and hence it is not requiring recovery of the fiscal aid granted to those beneficiaries in the context of any shareholdings held by a Spanish acquiring company, directly or indirectly in a foreign company before the date of publication [See footnote 1.] in the Official Journal of the European Union of the Commission Decision to initiate the formal investigation procedure under Article 88(2) of the Treaty, which could have then benefited from the measure at issue. Indeed, as of the date of the opening of the formal investigation and in line with its practice [See, inter alia, Commission Decision 2007/375/EC of 7 February 2007 concerning the exemption from excise duty on mineral oils used as fuel for alumina production in Gardanne, in the Shannon region and in Sardinia implemented by France, Ireland and Italy (OJ L 147, 8.6.2007, p. 29) and the Commission Decision of 24 June 2003 on the aid scheme implemented by Belgium, already cited, recital 79.], the Commission considers that any diligent trader should have taken into account the doubts it expressed as regards the compatibility of the measure at issue.

  • Judgment of the General Court (Ninth Chamber) of 15 November 2018. Deutsche Telekom AG v European Commission.Decision

    It should be recalled that in recitals 164 and 167 of the contested decision, the Commission found that the legitimate expectation entertained by the beneficiaries of the scheme at issue in the lawfulness of the scheme ended on 21 December …

    15 Nov 2018 · 62010TJ0207

  • Arrêt du Tribunal (huitième chambre) du 27 septembre 2023. Telefónica SA et Iberdrola, SA contre Commission européenne.Decision

    À cet égard, il est manifeste, au contraire, que les décisions initiales contiennent de nombreuses références explicites aux prises de participations indirectes. Celles-ci sont ainsi expressément visées dans les parties contenant la …

    27 Sep 2023 · 62015TJ0256

  • Judgment of the General Court (Eighth Chamber) of 27 September 2023. Banco Santander, SA and Others v European Commission.Decision

    On the contrary, it is clear that the initial decisions contain numerous explicit references to indirect acquisitions. Indirect acquisitions are explicitly referred to in the detailed description of the scheme set up by Article 12(5) of …

    27 Sep 2023 · 62015TJ0012

  • Arrêt du Tribunal (huitième chambre) du 27 septembre 2023. Ferrovial, SA e.a. contre Commission européenne.Decision

    À cet égard, il est manifeste, au contraire, que les décisions initiales contiennent de nombreuses références explicites aux prises de participations indirectes. Celles-ci sont ainsi expressément visées dans les parties contenant la …

    27 Sep 2023 · 62015TJ0252

  • Arrêt du Tribunal (huitième chambre) du 27 septembre 2023. Sociedad General de Aguas de Barcelona, SA contre Commission européenne.Decision

    À cet égard, il est manifeste, au contraire, que les décisions initiales contiennent de nombreuses références explicites aux prises de participations indirectes. Celles-ci sont ainsi expressément visées dans les parties contenant la …

    27 Sep 2023 · 62015TJ0253

  • Opinion of Advocate General Pitruzzella delivered on 21 January 2021. World Duty Free Group and Kingdom of Spain v European Commission.Decision

    On 28 October 2009, the Commission adopted the decision at issue, by which it closed the formal investigation procedure in respect of acquisitions of shareholdings within the European Union. Having stated in recital 19 of that decision …

    21 Jan 2021 · 62019CC0051

  • Arrêt du Tribunal (huitième chambre) du 27 septembre 2023. Royaume d'Espagne contre Commission européenne.Decision

    À cet égard, il est manifeste, au contraire, que les décisions initiales contiennent de nombreuses références explicites aux prises de participations indirectes. Celles-ci sont ainsi expressément visées dans les parties contenant la …

    27 Sep 2023 · 62014TJ0826

  • Opinion of Advocate General Pitruzzella delivered on 21 January 2021. Banco Santander, SA v European Commission.Decision

    On 28 October 2009, the Commission adopted the decision at issue, by which it closed the formal investigation procedure in respect of acquisitions of shareholdings within the European Union. Having stated in recital 19 of that decision …

    21 Jan 2021 · 62019CC0052

  • Judgment of the Court (Eighth Chamber) of 26 June 2025. European Commission v Kingdom of Spain and Others.Decision

    In the present case, it is expressly stated in Article 1(2) and recitals 167, 170 and 175 of Decision 2011/5, and in Article 1(2) and (4) and recital 210 of Decision 2011/282, that the exceptions to the cessation and recovery obligations …

    26 Jun 2025 · 62023CJ0776