166 VI. ASSESSMENT OF THE SCHEME › G. Recovery of the aid, Decision_act (EU) 2011/5

In forcesince 28 Oct 2009cited 7×

By these statements to Parliament, the Commission provided specific, unconditional and consistent assurances of a nature such that the beneficiaries of the measure at issue entertained justified hopes that the goodwill amortisation scheme was lawful, in the sense that it did not fall within the scope of State aid rules [On the principle of legitimate expectation, see the judgment of the Court of Justice in Van den Bergh en Jurgens BV v Commission, already cited, paragraph 44; judgment of the Court of Justice in Joined Cases C-182/03 and C-217/03 Forum 187 ASBL v Commission [2006] ECR I-5479, paragraph 147; and judgment of the Court of First Instance in Case T-290/97 Mehibas Dordtselaan v Commission [2000] ECR II-15, paragraph 59.], and that any advantages derived from it could not, therefore, be subject to subsequent recovery proceedings. Although these declarations did not amount to a formal Commission decision establishing that the amortisation scheme did not constitute State aid, their effect was equivalent from the point of view of the creation of a legitimate expectation, especially in view of the fact that the applicable procedures ensuring the respect of the collegiality principle had been followed in this case. As the notion of State aid is objective [Judgment of the Court of Justice in Case C-487/06 P British Aggregates v Commission, paragraphs 111-114 and 185 and 186; judgment of the Court of First Instance in Case T-98/00 Linde v Commission, paragraph 33.] and the Commission does not have any discretionary power as regards its interpretation — unlike what happens when assessing compatibility — any precise and unconditional statement on the Commission’s behalf to the effect that a national measure is not to be considered State aid will naturally be understood as meaning that the measure was ‘non-aid’ from the outset (i.e. also before the statement in question). Any undertaking which had previously been uncertain as to whether or not it would in future be liable, under the State aid rules, to recovery of advantages it had obtained under the goodwill amortisation scheme arising from transactions entered into before the Commission statements could have concluded thereafter that such uncertainty was unfounded, as it could not be expected to demonstrate greater diligence than the Commission in this respect. In these specific circumstances, and bearing in mind that Community law does not require the demonstration of a causal link between the assurances given by a Community institution and the behaviour by citizens or undertakings to which such assurances relate [i.e. it is not necessary to demonstrate that the individual or undertaking engaged in activities which it might not otherwise have done, in reliance on the assurance in question.], any diligent entrepreneur could reasonably expect the Commission subsequently not to impose any recovery [See, by analogy, the Commission Decision of 17 February 2003 on Belgian coordination centres (2003/757/EC) and the Commission Decision of 20 December 2006, GIE Fiscaux (C 46/2004).] as regards measures which it had itself previously classified, in a statement to another Community institution, as not constituting aid, irrespective of when the transaction benefiting from the aid measure was concluded.

  • Opinion of Advocate General Pitruzzella delivered on 21 January 2021. World Duty Free Group and Kingdom of Spain v European Commission.Decision

    On 28 October 2009, the Commission adopted the decision at issue, by which it closed the formal investigation procedure in respect of acquisitions of shareholdings within the European Union. Having stated in recital 19 of that decision …

    21 Jan 2021 · 62019CC0051

  • Judgment of the General Court (Ninth Chamber, Extended Composition) of 15 November 2018. World Duty Free Group, SA, formerly Autogrill EspañDecision

    The application of a transitional scheme was justified, according to the Commission, by the fact that it had provided specific, unconditional and consistent assurances of a nature such that the beneficiaries of the measure at issue had …

    15 Nov 2018 · 62010TJ0219(01)

  • Arrêt du Tribunal (neuvième chambre) du 15 novembre 2018. Banco Santander, SA contre Commission européenne.Decision

    L’application d’un tel régime transitoire se justifiait, selon la Commission, par le fait qu’elle avait offert des garanties spécifiques, inconditionnelles et concordantes d’une nature telle que les bénéficiaires de la mesure …

    15 Nov 2018 · 62010TJ0227

  • Opinion of Advocate General Pitruzzella delivered on 21 January 2021. Banco Santander, SA v European Commission.Decision

    On 28 October 2009, the Commission adopted the decision at issue, by which it closed the formal investigation procedure in respect of acquisitions of shareholdings within the European Union. Having stated in recital 19 of that decision …

    21 Jan 2021 · 62019CC0052

  • Arrêt du Tribunal (huitième chambre) du 27 septembre 2023. Telefónica SA et Iberdrola, SA contre Commission européenne.Decision

    Dans ces conditions, il ne saurait être exigé des requérantes qu’elles fassent preuve de plus de diligence que la Commission elle-même, ainsi que l’indique le considérant 166 de la première décision, auquel renvoie le point 89 …

    27 Sep 2023 · 62015TJ0256

  • Judgment of the General Court (Eighth Chamber) of 27 September 2023. Banco Santander, SA and Others v European Commission.Decision

    In those circumstances, the applicants cannot be required to exercise greater diligence than the Commission itself, as stated in recital 166 of the first decision, to which paragraph 89 of the judgment of 15 November 2018, Deutsche Telekom …

    27 Sep 2023 · 62015TJ0012

  • Arrêt du Tribunal (huitième chambre) du 27 septembre 2023. Sociedad General de Aguas de Barcelona, SA contre Commission européenne.Decision

    Dans ces conditions, il ne saurait être exigé de la requérante qu’elle fasse preuve de plus de diligence que la Commission elle-même, ainsi que l’indique le considérant 166 de la première décision, auquel renvoie le point 89 de …

    27 Sep 2023 · 62015TJ0253