III. COMMENTS SUBMITTED BY FRANCE, Decision_act (EU) 2007/51

In forcesince 18 Feb 2004
(52)

Lastly, if it was necessary to make the comparison on a case-by-case basis, the French authorities felt that farmers paying an annual charge to a water supply agency should under all circumstances be excluded from the scope of the comparison.

Table 1

Examples of actual aid rates for upgrading work under the PMPOA

[1 FRF = EUR 0,15]

(in FRF

Farm type

Improvements needed

Total amount for works (a)

Eligible amount for works (b)

Amount approved: State (c)

Amount approved: water agency (d)

Total aid (e)

Actual rate (e/b)

Mixed farm:

52 dairy cows, 20 sucklers plus replacements, or 120 UGBN

Sealing and covering exercise area. Increasing manure capacity. Construction of slurry pit.

334154

257372

236550

236550

141930

55,1 %

60 dairy cows and replacements, or 80 UGBN

Sealing existing pit. Construction of open pit. Sealing exercise area.

328178

328178

272038

272038

163222

49,7 %

90 dairy cows and replacements, or 120 UGBN

Creation of slurry. Increase in capacity of pit. Rainwater separation. Spreading plan.

1220700

671020

495800

495800

252780

36,7 %

Mixed farm: 450 fatstock pigs, 84 fatstock and dairy cattle, or 115 UGBN

Increase to 9 months in waste storage capacity. Coverage of exercise area. Water fountain for pigs.

196380

188330

177225

177225

115195

57,5 %

147 sows, 27 boars, 1840 fatstock pigs, or 223 UGBN

Separate water network. Covering of runs.

93180

305510

16163

16163

10505

34,4 %

210 sows, 1318 fatstock pigs, or 167 UGBN.

Sealing slurry pit. Drainage network. Multi-phase supply.

100293

55375

55375

55375

33225

60 %

242000 laying poultry, or 1128 UGBN

Droppings removal and drying installation.

1575200

547700

310930

310930

186558

34,6 %

Table 2

Examples of actual aid rates in the case of the construction of new buildings

(in FRF)

Type of farm

Improvements needed

Estimated cost of old buildings (a)

Total amount for works (b)

Amount approved: State (c)

Amount approved: water agency (d)

Total aid (e)

Actual rate (e/b)

80 dairy cows and replacements, or 123 UGBN

Construction of straw pens for all animals. Installation of gutters.

380120

468502

328640

90880

118592

25,3 %

75 sucklers and replacements, or 116 UGBN

Construction of open-run housing. Increase in slurry and dung storage.

280634

741807

212436

111211

97094

13,1 %

82 sucklers and replacements, or 134 UGBN

Construction of open-run housing. Sealing of concrete areas. Increase in slurry and dung storage.

605565

1197152

437153

196951

190231

15,9 %

70 sucklers and renewals, or 110 UGBN

Construction of open-run housing. Sealing of concrete areas. Construction of slurry pit.

160940

565612

88550

6000

26565

4,7 %

34650 laying hens, or 214 UGBN

Construction of coops. Droppings storage area. Installation of droppings drier.

368454

2309993

368454

176454

163472

7,1 %