96 IV. ASSESSMENT › 3. Examination of the compatibility of the aid, Decision_act (EU) 2007/51

In forcesince 18 Feb 2004

The Commission has already expressed its opinion on that problem as part of State aid N 355/2000, in authorising the continuation of the PMPOA from 2001 to 2006. In line with the arguments invoked at the time, the Commission today insists that it cannot ignore the fact that the initial French action programme implementing the nitrates Directive was only adopted in 1997 and that the actual initial obligations imposed on livestock rearers on the spot, transposing that programme, are subsequent to that date. Even if it seems clear that France did not exercise due diligence in transposing the Directive and that it should have adopted the necessary provisions within time limits long since passed [It should be noted that as the result of infringement proceedings brought against France the Commission took France to the Court of Justice for incorrect application of the nitrates Directive. The Court held against France for failure to take the appropriate steps to identify waters affected by pollution and consequently to designate the corresponding vulnerable zones (Court of Justice judgment in Case C-258/00, Commission v France, ECR [2002] I-05959).], it cannot be denied that the initial obligations of which the livestock rearers were aware were much more recent.

  • Judgment of the Court (Sixth Chamber) of 27 June 2002. Commission of the European Communities v French Republic.Decision

    27 Jun 2002 · 62000CJ0258