Recital 41, Decision_act (EU) 2001/851

In force

With regard to the investments scheduled in the five-year plans, the Commission had, in its decision initiating the investigation procedure, expressed doubts regarding the arrangements for financing the investments needed to provide the subsidised services under the 1991 agreement. In particular, it wanted to check the extent to which the costs of ship acquisition and depreciation entered into the calculation of the annual compensation. In addition, the fact that Tirrenia was guaranteed a subsidy which included the cost of depreciation of its fleet until 2008 could, according to the Commission, be assimilated to an implicit guarantee on the part of the Italian State, enabling the public operator not to shoulder the economic risk inherent in any investment.

The first point to be borne in mind is that Tirrenia is obliged under the agreement to use vessels less than 20 years old on its subsidised routes and that it must normally own these vessels unless an exemption is expressly granted by the public authorities. This obligation, which constitutes a public service obligation, has led Tirrenia to renew a substantial part of its fleet in the last few years, given the age reached by the vessels used on the routes referred to in the first five-year plan (1990 to 1994). In addition, the type of vessels to be used on each of the different routes served by Tirrenia is laid down by a ministerial decree approving or amending each five-year plan. The acquisition of any new ship, just like the transfer or decommissioning of the oldest ships, has to be authorised by ministerial decree, which also specifies the service to which the vessel is to be assigned. Tirrenia's investments must also be in line with its strategy to develop the services provided by the public operator during the five-year reference period, a strategy provided for in the five-year plan approved by the public authority.

Given this legal context, the Commission has checked whether, during the 1990 to 1994 and 1995 to 1999 five-year periods, the costs of acquiring new ships and the depreciation costs of the vessels used by Tirrenia di Navigazione on the public service lines (a) fulfilled the requirements set by the Italian authorities and (b) were taken into account in a proportionate manner when calculating the annual compensation.

The Commission observes that, when Tirrenia introduced new vessels, older vessels were at the same time decommissioned, with the result that there was no overall increase in capacity linked to the renewal of the public operator's fleet.

As far as the cost of acquiring the new vessels is concerned, information provided by the Italian authorities shows that these purchases were made partly with the company's own resources and partly by means of bank loans. It also appears that the rates charged by the credit institutions involved are in line with rates enjoyed during the same period by companies of comparable size and turnover in other sectors of the economy(29). It appears, moreover, that Tirrenia di Navigazione did not enjoy any direct guarantee from the Italian authorities regarding the repayment of these loans. The Commission acknowledges that the very existence of an agreement with the State assured investors that their commitments would be honoured and enabled Tirrenia to modernise its fleet without bearing the economic risks which would have been borne by a commercial operator. This advantage, which could be assimilated to an implicit guarantee(30) and thus constitute State aid within the meaning of Article 87(1) of the Treaty, is, however, intrinsic to the agreement, concluded for a duration of 20 years before the entry into force of Regulation (EEC) No 3577/92 and the Community guidelines on State aid to maritime transport (OJ C 207, 5.7.1997). In addition, as already noted, the new vessels acquired by Tirrenia pursuant to the agreement are assigned exclusively to the line services provided for under the five-year plans. Consequently, this advantage, which is an integral part of the public service agreement, qualifies for the exemption referred to in Article 86(2) of the Treaty.

Regarding the depreciation costs of ships used by Tirrenia on the routes referred to in the five-year plans, the Commission notes that these are one of the cost elements which, under the terms of Article 5 of the agreement, enter into the calculation of the annual subsidy. Depreciation is calculated linearly over a 20-year period, with the exception of ultra-high-speed vessels, for which the duration is limited to 15 years. As the depreciation of vessels used to serve connections recognised as being of general interest by the Italian authorities is calculated according to criteria laid down in the agreement, and as examination of the analytical accounts of these routes has revealed no element of overcompensation in this respect in the two five-year periods considered, the Commission believes that the mechanism the agreement introduced to take vessel depreciation into account when calculating the annual compensation may be authorised under Article 86(2) of the Treaty. The provision of services recognised as being of general interest presupposes the use of vessels of a type and capacity predetermined by the public authorities and whose depreciation may thus be taken into account when calculating the annual compensation provided the vessels in question were acquired by the company under normal market conditions and in order to meet the obligations placed on it and are used exclusively for regular transport services on the routes covered by the agreement. In the case of Tirrenia di Navigazione, the Commission notes that all the vessels in question are used exclusively for services on routes recognised as being of general interest and that, as a result, their depreciation may be taken into account in its totality when the annual subsidy is calculated. The same is true for the investments needed to provide the services prescribed by the Italian authorities for the 2000 to 2004 five-year period and which correspond, in terms of type and capacity, to the commitments entered into by these same authorities concerning the requisite service level.