Recital 37, Decision_act (EU) 2001/851

In force

In examining the proportionality of the aid paid to Tirrenia, the Commission became aware of a study by an independent consultant (hereinafter the "Azzurra study")(24), commissioned by a complainant, regarding the projected profitability of the routes operated by Tirrenia within the terms of the agreement. The analysis is based on the projected operating results of a fictitious company, Azzurra di Navigazione, subject to the same regularity, frequency, capacity and vessel-type requirements to which Tirrenia was subject in 1997, on the medium- and long-distance national connections operated by Tirrenia. The study divides the routes operated by Azzurra into three categories: clearly profitable, more or less in balance and loss-making. Taking 1999 as the reference year, the study also shows that Azzurra would have obtained a positive net operating result, for its routes as a whole, of ITL 21722 million. However, information forwarded by the Italian authorities, which supplied analytical accounts for Tirrenia, drawn up by an independent expert, revealed that for the same year, 1999, the public operator made a net operating loss of ITL 21252 million. Moreover, while for certain routes Tirrenia's operating results are quite close to those of Azzurra, the situation is quite different on the other routes. In the light of these discrepancies, the Commission called on an independent consultant to pinpoint the reasons for them and establish or rule out the existence of any overcompensation.