With regard to the routes where competition exists from private operators, the Commission has ascertained the following:
Naples/Palermo
No competitors meet the requirements of annual regularity and frequency of service as set out in the agreement, for either passenger or goods transport. Since 1997 a private company has been operating the route during the high season (April to October); however, it offers services of limited capacity and involving only rapid passenger transport, and is therefore unable to meet the service requirements laid down by the Italian public authorities, which are basically for a year-round daily night-time sailing from each of the two ports.
Civitavecchia/Olbia
A private operator operating between Civitavecchia and Golfo Aranci(19) has been competing with Tirrenia on this route during the high season since 1996, and year-round since 1998. Competition increased in June 2000 with the arrival of another operator(20). The Commission nevertheless notes that only Tirrenia di Navigazione meets all the requirements of the agreement, in terms both of frequencies (seven days a week, year-round) and of ports to be served and departure times, including a night-time sailing from both ports during the high season. The Commission notes in particular that neither of the two competing operators provides a year-round daily link and that, in the low season, the cumulated service supplied by these operators does not guarantee the daily frequency required by the agreement.
The Commission also notes that Tirrenia di Navigazione offers additional services on this route, the frequency of which may vary according to changes in demand. Pursuant to the Ministerial Decree of 13 March 1998, these services may be carried out from June to September, alternating departures from Fiumicino and Golfo Aranci(21), thus giving Tirrenia additional operational flexibility. The Commission would stress once again that, in the absence of a precise prior definition of the level of services required, these latter services cannot be regarded as meeting public service requirements.
Genoa/Porto Torres
For the passenger segment on this route, Tirrenia di Navigazione has faced competition from private operators since 1994 in the high season and since 1999 in the low season. The Commission notes, however, that in both the high and the low season, no competing operator meets all the regularity, frequency and timetable requirements laid down by the agreement, including in particular a year-round daily night-time sailing from each of the two ports. The Commission also notes that as the private operators do not have replacement vessels they are sometimes forced to suspend services for maintenance reasons and sometimes deploy their ships on more profitable services, such as cruises.
The Commission also notes that, in the high season, Tirrenia di Navigazione offers additional high-speed services, the precise frequency of which is laid down by the current rules. The same is true of additional freight services, performed using a ro-ro ferry according to traffic requirements. As the Commission has already indicated, in the absence of a precise prior definition of the level of services required, these services cannot be regarded as meeting public service requirements.
Genoa/Olbia/Arbatax
Only since 1998, and only in the high season, has Tirrenia faced competition from private operators on this route. The Commission notes in this respect that only Tirrenia di Navigazione meets all the regularity, frequency and timetable requirements laid down by the agreement, which provides for a year-round daily night-time sailing from each of the two ports and two weekly extensions to the port of Arbatax, which no competing operator offers. The Commission also notes that the high-speed services Tirrenia offers on this route during the summer, as laid down in the agreement, are not offered by its competitors.
Finally, the Commission notes that, pursuant to the Ministerial Decree of 9 October 1998, Tirrenia also serves the ports of La Spezia and Golfo Aranci(22) with one daily sailing from June to September.
Livorno/Cagliari
Tirrenia di Navigazione carries freight on this route in competition with two private operators, whose cumulated service offer appears to meet the agreement's requirements in terms of regularity, frequency and capacity. One of these operators has been operating the route since 1995, and the other since 1998. The established presence of these operators calls into question the need to provide compensation for the loss made by the public operator on this route. The Commission notes, however, that only Tirrenia di Navigazione guarantees uninterrupted year-round services as specified in the current rules; in other words, Tirrenia maintains a replacement ship, on a route on which the ship must be less than 20 years old. The Commission notes that these requirements involve specific additional costs for the public operator not incurred by the private operators. The Commission therefore considers that these additional costs, and only these, may give rise to compensation. None the less, the Italian authorities need to ensure that the amount of the compensation paid is strictly proportionate to the additional costs generated by the said public service requirements.
Voltri/Termini Imerese
Tirrenia uses ro-ro vessels on this route to provide cargo transport services, in competition with services offered by a private operator using mixed passenger/goods vessels on the parallel route Genoa/Palermo(23). The Commission notes that the services offered by the private operator satisfy the public service requirements set out in the agreement in terms of capacity and frequency. While the need for compensation has been established for the earlier five-year periods, before the private operator became established and thus before it was able properly to meet all these requirements, the same cannot be said for the new five-year period. In this context, the Commission notes the Italian authorities' undertaking to cancel the services offered by Tirrenia on this route for that period; these will accordingly no longer be taken into account when calculating the public service compensation amount.