To enable the Commission to check that the compensation paid has been proportional to the public service requirements, the Italian authorities sent it an analysis of the operating accounts for each of the routes served by the public operator over the last 10 years. The analysis showed some routes to be profitable overall on an annual basis, even if they sometimes present a somewhat substantial deficit in the winter period, while others are loss-making overall. The routes which are profitable overall are essentially those on which the competition of private operators is focused.
The Commission notes that the mechanism for calculating the annual compensation described above is such that the net positive result of the routes which show an overall profit helps to reduce the amount of compensation awarded, and thus to ensure its proportionality.