To determine whether the annual compensation paid to Tirrenia corresponds to the minimum needed to provide services which meet the public service requirements laid down by the Italian authorities, the Commission needs to examine all the parameters which generate additional costs for the public operator for the services it has provided.
The Commission notes that the compensation calculation mechanism provides for income made during the high season to help reduce the deficits accumulated in the low season, with the result that the resulting level of annual compensation remains lower overall than it would be if the accumulated deficits alone were added together, route by route. The Commission also notes that the company's proceeds are subject to a dual constraint in terms of fares, namely the preferential fares for certain social categories and the need for the company to obtain the public authorities' approval for any change in the fares. The information forwarded by the Italian authorities shows that Tirrenia is not free to adapt its fares to take account, in particular, of changes in operating costs. This dual constraint, which leads to an appreciable reduction in the company's income, and which is reflected in the amount of the annual compensation, cannot be described under such circumstances as an aggressive commercial policy, characterised by predatory pricing.
Secondly, the Commission notes that the cost elements taken into consideration in order to calculate the compensation have been defined by the public authorities, leaving the company with no margin of discretion. These elements reflect all the fixed and variable costs directly linked to providing the services classified by the public authorities as services of general interest and which, as such, are covered by the agreement previously cited (see Table I, recital 38). These cost elements include depreciation of vessels and expenditure on fuel and mineral oils. Regarding ship depreciation, the Commission considers that, to the extent that the ships in question are used exclusively for the services covered by the agreement, this cost element may be regarded as necessary for the provision of those services, and may thus legitimately enter into the calculation of the annual compensation. Regarding the cost of fuels and mineral oils used by these ships, the Commission has found no discriminatory element reducing the cost of such fuels and lubricants to the benefit of Tirrenia di Navigazione compared with other maritime operators.