The Commission also notes that, under the system introduced by the 1991 agreement, Tirrenia operates on international routes, the net operating deficits of which have been taken into account when calculating the annual subsidy. This applies to the Italy/Malta route and the Cagliari/Trapani/Tunis route.
The Commission would point out that these routes are in the international maritime transport market and not the Italian cabotage market. As this market is subject to actual or potential competition from other Community operators, such compensation is to be analysed as operating aid, which may only be authorised pursuant to Article 86(2).
Information supplied by the Italian authorities shows that the Italy/Malta route was operated on a year-round basis until 1992. The arrival on the market of competitors during the summer season led the Italian authorities to restrict the service obligation to the winter period from 1993 to 1994 and to suspend services on this route entirely as from June 1994. Under these circumstances, the Commission considers that, in the absence of comparable services offered by other Community or non-member country operators, the compensation paid to Tirrenia up to that date was needed to meet the service requirements laid down by the Italian authorities. In addition, in the absence of proven competition from other Community operators, the compensation paid to Tirrenia to cover the net deficit for operating this route was not of a nature to affect trade between Member States to an extent contrary to the common interest.
As for the Cagliari/Trapani/Tunis route, the Commission observes that the link to Tunisia is an extension of the Cagliari/Trapani cabotage route on which Tirrenia operates without competition. Information forwarded by the Italian authorities shows that the services performed on the international part of the route do not entail any additional financial burden which may be taken into account when calculating the annual compensation. The figures supplied for the years 1993 to 1996 inclusively show a net positive result for the Trapani/Tunis connection, which itself helped reduce the deficit recorded for the Cagliari/Trapani link and in turn the negative sum taken into account to calculate the annual compensation.
Need for compensation