Tirrenia di Navigazione submitted its comments on the decision to initiate the procedure by letter dated 22 November 1999. Primarily, the company contested the notion that the compensation paid pursuant to the agreements signed with the State can be qualified as "new aid" and hence the legitimacy of the decision to initiate the formal investigation procedure. According to the company, the Commission had known for a long time of the existence of a scheme for public service obligation compensations and had never raised any objections to the scheme. The company also contended that the value of the annual compensation payments paid to the public operator is strictly necessary and proportional to cover the additional net cost of the public service obligations. Tirrenia concluded, therefore, that there was no obstacle to competition with other market operators.
At the same time, Tirrenia di Navigazione instituted proceedings before the Court of First Instance pursuant to Article 230(4) of the Treaty(8) against the Commission's decision to initiate the procedure.