, Special Report No 17/98 on support for renewable energy sources in the shared-cost actio…

In force

3.22. The audit of 13 THERMIE projects showed that the application or interpretation of several selection criteria raised fundamental questions. Six out of 13 projects, in the areas of both solar-photovoltaic and biomass, showed only limited innovative elements. While the THERMIE information brochure 1994 to 1995 defines eligible costs as the costs related to the innovative part of the project, the Commission had also funded the non-innovative parts. This led to the conclusion that these projects were more like RES promotion or investment projects than true demonstration projects as defined in the Council Decision and the THERMIE work programme. In two of the 13 projects the only project partner not coming from the same Member State as the other partners in the consortium was found to be an affiliated company with a negligible role in the project. In another six projects the only 'foreign` project partner was merely a normal supplier of standard parts who did not participate in the innovative part of the project, as far as any innovation existed. The lack of real, new international cooperation shows that these projects lack a European added value. This implies that the projects should have been supported on a national level.

3.23. The eligibility criteria, specified in the THERMIE Information Brochure 1996, explain under 'transnational collaboration` that 'the collaboration must be more than symbolic and the proposal must show a significant and balanced participation between project partners`. On the financial level this rule is not applied. Whilst in JOULE projects all industrial project partners contribute 50 % towards their own costs, in THERMIE this was not the case. In all projects the funding structure was such that the future owner/user of the installation paid the full difference between the total project costs, including the costs of all project partners, and the Commission contribution. Therefore the costs of the partners who built the installations were fully reimbursed and they did not contribute financially to the project. In two projects it was found that a partner had even charged commercial prices for the execution of his tasks instead of cost price.