, Special Report No 17/98 on support for renewable energy sources in the shared-cost actio…

In force

3.45. Out of the 17 audited JOULE projects, six were coordinated by three different EEIGs. Although the consortium partners were satisfied that the administrative tasks were delegated to a separate entity, which in two cases was located close to the Commission, in none of the cases had the use of an EEIG resulted in easier or faster contract negotiations. On the contrary, there were several additional problems.

3.46. Contracts coordinated by an EEIG are signed by the EEIG on behalf of all members. The actual members are only mentioned in the technical annex. However, the technical annex gives no information regarding the distribution of the Community contribution between the members. This means that the only sources of information regarding the 'budgets` of the individual members, are the contract negotiation forms. As these forms are not part of the actual contract, the members could change the distribution amongst themselves without the Commission's approval. This situation may reduce the authority of the Commission and it certainly reduces the transparency of the contracts. The Commission should extend the table 'Estimated breakdown of allowable costs` in all contracts with EEIGs to include the distribution of funds between the participating EEIG members.

3.47. The Commission's internal negotiation guidelines for EEIGs show that it does not accept that within one contract some EEIG members would work under the additional cost model (6), while others apply the full cost model (7). This does not allow a university (which uses the additional cost model) and a private company (which is obliged to adopt the full cost model) to participate as members of the same EEIG. If the contract with the EEIG discloses the actual distribution of the contribution over the participating members, this rule would seem superfluous.

Difficulties in producing correct cost statements

3.48. The system of real cost contracts requires analytical accounts to be kept in order to complete cost statements and avoid the misuse of Community funds. In the JOULE and THERMIE contracts audited the justification of claimed costs was often unsatisfactory. The findings confirmed prior reports of the Court on RTD programmes, which use the same model contract.