, Special Report No 17/98 on support for renewable energy sources in the shared-cost actio…

In force

3.30. In JOULE and THERMIE at least three scientific officers with temporary contracts were responsible for projects in which their previous employers were involved. Although there were no indications that this had influenced the management and control of these projects, conflicts of interest could be created.

3.31. At one THERMIE contractor the office of the TTM (a semi-public technical monitoring agency) not only worked for the Commission but also provided a technical supervision service, on the same project, to the beneficiary. In the case mentioned in paragraph 3.18 the project proposal had been evaluated by the same TTM who was later assigned to monitor the project. Both situations could result in conflicts of interest, and should have been avoided.

3.32. Financial checks are limited to the reasonableness of contractors' cost claims and review of project budget outturn. The high number of problems encountered in the cost statements of the audited contractors clearly indicates that a serious review of the costs is not performed. None of the contractors selected by the Court had been audited by the Commission. According to the Commission, during the earlier JOULE II programme, only 5 % of the contractors had been audited. This means that the chance of being audited (1:20) is very small for JOULE contractors. In the previous THERMIE programme a higher number of contractors was audited than in JOULE. The results of the Court's audits imply that the number of audits should be extended in the present programme, especially in the JOULE area.

3.33. The information system AMPERE-AQUA which is used in JOULE for the monitoring of the programme and project execution is an inadequate tool for day to day management. Because the system is not 'user-friendly`, important data like the receipt of technical reports, required to control the project's progress and adherence to actual contract terms, had not been entered. Other data for monitoring the Commission's own performance, such as the delay between the receipt of a cost claim and the actual payment, were not available.