, Special Report No 17/98 on support for renewable energy sources in the shared-cost actio…

In force

3.14. The preparation of a project proposal involves a significant investment of the applicant's time and money. Information provided to potential applicants on how to write a proposal has improved since the start of the programme, especially in JOULE, and contractors indicated that an extensive proposal was required to enable a fair evaluation. However, the creation of standard electronic forms for proposals as is already the case in other programmes, could improve the efficiency of the process.

3.15. The selection process in JOULE, which is described in detail in Annex 2, follows the standards of the 4th FWP, depending heavily on the judgment of external experts. During the first call for proposals for JOULE in 1995 the original consensus report proposed classifications for 143 out of 563 proposals in the RES area which were reclassified downwards by the Programme management before submission to the JOULE Committee. Although the changes were justified as harmonising classifications for individual criteria from individual experts and the final consensus marks, the need for this harmonisation implies that the instructions to evaluators and to the Commission staff who chaired the panel discussions, were not sufficiently clear. In order to avoid the recurrence of the problems of the first call, the Commission clarified the written instructions for evaluators and Commission staff.

3.16. Although THERMIE is part of the 4th FWP it does not apply the same standard procedures. Its selection procedure was less formalised, less documented and hence less clear than for JOULE. Instead of the six external experts who evaluate a JOULE proposal, THERMIE proposals are examined by two external experts, one or two scientific officers at the Commission and, in theory, by all members of the relevant THERMIE Technical Committee. The members of the THERMIE Committees are representatives of the Member States. Their participation is not limited to a supervisory role, as in the JOULE Committee, but involves actual participation in the technical evaluation of specific projects. As a selection process which aims to evaluate proposals only on their scientific merits without being influenced by political pressure, the JOULE system appears preferable.

  • celex=31994D0806