, Special Report No 17/98 on support for renewable energy sources in the shared-cost actio…

In force

7.2. The merger between JOULE and THERMIE, which was intended to integrate the RTD and demonstration phases into a coherent strategy covering the whole innovation process, from scientific breakthrough all the way to dissemination, has not been fully achieved. The gap between RTD and demonstration still exists, mainly because THERMIE supports the construction of large production units rather than of genuine innovative installations. The lack of harmonised project selection, management and administrative procedures in both areas underlines the problem (see paragraphs 3.02, 3.16, 3.24. 3.29, 3.35 and 3.36).

7.3. Many of the THERMIE demonstration projects were found to lack a major innovative aspect; they had only a limited European dimension and their funding structure could not guarantee equal participation by all contractors. As a consequence they would have been better placed in the energy technology promotion programme (THERMIE II), proposed by the Commission in 1994, but not adopted by the Council (see paragraphs 3.22, 3.23 and 3.24).

7.4. Proper scientific and financial management, monitoring and control of all projects under JOULE, THERMIE and Altener is not guaranteed. The widespread use of external assistance by DG XVII has made it possible for supervision to be closer than for JOULE. The introduction of external cluster managers to supervise JOULE projects in 1997 may improve the situation. Both DGs should try to harmonise the role of external assistants. It remains vital that the Commission ensures the adequate monitoring of the experts (see paragraphs 3.26 to 3.35, 4.13 to 4.16).

7.5. The annual and five-year external evaluations (21) of the JOULE-THERMIE programme confirm many of the observations of the Court and should be followed closely by the Commission, as far as management is concerned, during the implementation of the Fifth Framework programme. The technical and scientific evaluation in the reports should however be strengthened (see paragraphs 3.38 to 3.41).

7.6. The Commission should avoid conflicts of interest in the fields of project selection, management and supervision (see paragraphs 3.17, 3.18, 3.30, 3.31).

  • Judgment of the Court of 24 October 1989. Commission of the European Communities v Council of the European Communities.Decision

    24 Oct 1989 · 61988CJ0016