, Special Report No 17/98 on support for renewable energy sources in the shared-cost actio…

In force

3.17. In the JOULE as well as the THERMIE Committees, some Member States were represented by staff members of public or semi-public research institutes that also participated as contractors in the programme. Although the scientific hands-on experience of these experts is certainly valuable in the discussions, a position on the committees may give their institutes an unfair 'information` advantage over their competitors.

3.18. Another incompatibility may arise in a contract where the external expert who evaluated the proposal was also assigned by the Commission to do the scientific monitoring of the project as a THERMIE Technical Manager (TTM). If an expert first evaluates a proposal positively it could be difficult for the same expert to be critical about the execution of the same project.

3.19. From the receipt of proposals until the Commission Decision to fund projects takes on average four months. The negotiation phase between the decision and the actual signature of the contracts adds another four to five months, during which specific terms and conditions (mainly financial) of the contract are negotiated. Although all parties consider the negotiation period to be too long, in many cases discussions within project consortia or the late replies of individual partners in consortia to Commission queries were themselves a cause of delay. Significant shortening of the negotiation period might be achievable by revision of procedures, in particular a clarification and simplification of the standard contract.