3.20. One of the JOULE Solar Thermal projects audited was the first phase of a much larger project. The next phases of this project will be entered for evaluation in subsequent calls for proposals, where they risk not being selected. As the project can only produce relevant results if all phases are executed, the Commission takes a considerable risk of wasting money. In the information presented to the JOULE Committee, the priority list contains no reference to the fact that the ECU two million project concerns only the first two years of a six year project. While the proposal summary mentions this fact, it neither explains which technical part is covered by the first phase, nor what the total financial value of the whole project will be. This means that the information provided to the JOULE Committee was inadequate to assess the proposal in the proper context. The JOULE Committee should be informed in more detail about proposals for parts of projects. A Solar Thermal project in THERMIE was divided into phases in a similar way, but the THERMIE Committee had been informed adequately.
3.21. The average cost of experts for evaluating one JOULE proposal was approximately ECU 655, which represents for each contract almost ECU 2 600, 3,2 % of the average project contribution. The average cost of experts per proposal for THERMIE was higher than for JOULE although a THERMIE proposal is reviewed by only two external experts, instead of a maximum of six experts in JOULE. The Commission did not monitor or evaluate the costs of the procedure. Detailed information on its related internal costs for staff and infrastructure was not available. This lack of cost information and awareness was not limited to the selection procedure, but was found in the entire programme management, no attempt being made to determine best practice.