4.6. The audit focused on category (b) of the support measures, the pilot actions. The definition of this category in the Council Decision mentioned training and information activities and sectoral actions. These latter are grouped into four themes; tools, planning, information/training and financial. An examination of the list of project titles revealed that it often concerned the development of implementation plans for RES or strategy or feasibility studies for the use of certain RES types in specific areas, regions or industries. Many of these titles could also have come under the JOULE component of JOULE-THERMIE in the field of 'integration of Renewable Energies`, or as a type B action in the THERMIE component. More transparency and efficiency could be achieved by concentrating the support given to a certain type of action in one programme.
4.7. The distribution of the Altener funds between the Member States shows that there is no correlation between the level of the contribution from JOULE-THERMIE and the level of the Altener contribution. That is to say that some Member States which are hardly involved in any JOULE-THERMIE funded RTD or demonstration projects receive substantial support for the promotion of RES from Altener.
Programme management and control
Project selection
4.8. The selection procedures in Altener for the pilot projects, which represent 66 % of all contributions, are completely different from the JOULE and THERMIE procedures. Instead of publishing calls for proposals in the Official Journal of the European Communities, the Altener proposals have to be brought forward by Member State representatives in the Altener Management Committee. The categories or types of proposals which can be entered each year are defined in annual guidelines, which are established by the Commission in cooperation with the committee. These guidelines do not contain any directives on the way Member States have to collect proposals or whether they should pre-select proposals or not. The Commission services had no information on how different Member States dealt with this matter.
4.9. Every proposal is subsequently evaluated by two Commission officials who draft a concise consensus report. On the basis of the consensus reports the programme management establishes a priority and reserve list, in which it proposes projects for funding to the Altener Committee.