3.24. As indicated above six of the 13 audited THERMIE projects do not have an innovative character and therefore are not eligible under the JOULE-THERMIE programme. They would have fitted in the energy technology promotion programme, which the Commission proposed to the Council under the name THERMIE-II (5), but which was not approved. Even the proposal evaluation forms show that in the selection procedure the innovation aspects are considered less essential than would be expected from an RTD programme. Although the forms, which are filled out by external experts, require the expert to summarise 'aim description and innovation aspects of the project`, the form's section on 'project appraisal` does not require the expert to appraise the innovation aspects. The criteria which have to be appraised are: previous activities, technical and financial risk, replication potential, economic viability, environment and safety aspects and dissemination capability. The Council's objective with the merger of JOULE-THERMIE - to integrate the RTD and demonstration phases - has not been realised. While JOULE has increased the involvement of industrial project partners, THERMIE did not take truly innovative results of JOULE projects to the demonstration phase. THERMIE continues to support installations which are hardly innovative, but which need public support because they are not economically viable. Only one project was the follow-up of a prior JOULE II (3rd FWP) project.
3.25. The application of selection criteria for photovoltaic (PV) projects revealed a specific problem. One of the main THERMIE eligibility criteria is economic viability, as one of the objectives of THERMIE is to show the economic advantages of new technology. The standard project proposal evaluation forms therefore include the pay-back period of a project. In all PV proposals the pay-back period or other financial indicators were disclosed by the applicants, but the PV evaluation summaries did not include this information. Some PV proposals had pay-back periods as high as 77 or even 121 years, which far exceed the expected lifetimes of the installations. The fact that grid-connected PV-installations are not financially viable should not be neglected. It raises the question whether the focus in the area of photovoltaics should not be more towards basic research than towards the demonstration of uneconomic installations which need massive public support.
Project management and control