7.5. Fraud against the Community budget is often transnational. The enforcement agencies, however, operate according to a huge number of different procedures and in dispersed order in a very time-consuming way. In contrast the fraudsters themselves can operate in real time using their international networks of contacts. The procedures in place can simply not cope with the new criminal networks. Assistance from the Commission and the information exchange between UCLAF and the judicial authorities of Member States constitute the beginning of a solution. However, a major obstacle still is the lack of common standards of evidence, which prevents Member States from accepting evidence gathered in other Member States. Therefore a 'European Law Enforcement Area` (56) with clear, limited objectives reflecting the specific responsibilities of the institutions regarding the protection of the Community's financial interests is necessary.
7.6. UCLAF has to play a difficult role. It has administrative tasks in relation to the protection of the financial interests of the Community which belong to the first pillar but also it has responsibilities related to judicial investigations, which belong to the third pillar, without support from an independent European judicial authority able, to launch and direct investigations and bring prosecutions as appropriate. The liaison and criminal law expertise interface described in paragraph 3.4 only represents a preliminary solution to the existing problems (57). On 25 November 1997 the Commission presented a communication to the Parliament Committee on Budgetary Control (DOC(SEC97) 2182/2) entitled 'Improving Action against Incompetence, Financial Irregularities, Fraud and Corruption`.
7.7. UCLAF has no competence to carry out enquiries related to the other Community institutions. In the Community context this has to be considered as a serious weakness in the legal and organisational framework of the fight against fraud. Priority should be given to finding a solution to this problem and any proposal for the reorganisation of the fight against fraud at European level should address this. In this context it is also necessary to define the responsibilities of Europol and UCLAF in such a way that synergy effects can be ensured.
This report was adopted by the Court of Auditors in Luxembourg at its meeting of 10 and 11 June 1998.
For the Court of Auditors
Bernhard FRIEDMANN
President