5.5. For 1996 IRENE contains 645 cases in the field of traditional own resources transmitted by the Member States with a total value of 123,1 Mio ECU. In the 1996 Annual Report on Fight against Fraud 1 950 cases are indicated with a total amount of 320 Mio ECU. A footnote explains that this includes an estimate for the second half year. The practice in past years was to multiply the number/amount of the first six months by two. Thus there is a significant difference between the published figure and the figures available in IRENE.
5.6. The problem as it relates to own resources should not occur in the future, as Member States are required, according to Council Regulation (EC) No 1355/96 (44), to report more frequently, i.e. every three months on irregularity cases detected (see paragraph 4.9).
5.7. The figures in Table 5 presented as 'Irregularities detected by the Commission in cooperation with Member States` are composed of the estimates of the financial importance of cases held by UCLAF. These cases come from a variety of sources and should in theory be the total of the cases held in the UCLAF Pre-IRENE database. As the Pre-IRENE database is not yet fully operational the figures for only one of the four units were produced from this source. For the other three units a note was prepared for the unit in charge of drafting the Annual Report giving a total amount of the estimated financial value of the cases held. Examination of these figures showed that some 88 % of the amounts given were attributable to only 12 % of the cases. The amount recorded for the estimated VAT, lost to the Communities own resources, in relation to work done by the cigarettes and alcohol task forces in 1996 amounted to some 36 % of the total financial impact of the category. This amount should not be directly compared to the figures formally communicated by the Member States.
5.8. The total value of cases in Table 5 is higher than the actual value of the cases held in Pre-IRENE (2 460 Mio ECU) as 49 of them have more than one source and are therefore counted more than once in the table above. More than 142 cases are held in Pre-IRENE where no source is registered.