, Special Report No 8/98 on the Commission's services specifically involved in the fight a…

In forcesince 10 Jun 1998

5.1. The figures presented by the Commission in the annual reports on Fight against Fraud related to the impact of irregularities on the Community Budget show the financial importance of 'Irregularities formally communicated by the Member States` alongside figures relating to 'Irregularities detected by the Commission in cooperation with Member States`.

5.2. In recent publications these figures have been presented as a type of performance indicator comparing average cases size and total of the irregularities in the two categories (41). The Commission itself presented, in its 1996 Annual Report on Fight against Fraud, similar reflections. According to the text, approved by the Commission, the average budgetary impact of cases under investigation by the Commission (i.e. those not formally communicated by Member States) is 1,6 Mio ECU. Cases of fraud or irregularity notified by Member States under the various regulations reach an average amount of 130 000 ECU.

5.3. According to the Commission, less than 5 % of all the cases detected are dealt with by the Commission in close collaboration with the investigation authorities in the Member States. On an aggregate basis, these cases account for more than half of the amounts involved (42). This reflects a deliberate choice by the Commission to concentrate its efforts on combatting organised or sophisticated fraud. Such fraud, the origin of which is often characterised by the participation of persons or firms operating from one or many countries is difficult for the Member States to identify without the active support which can only be given at the Community level (43).

Reliability of data

5.4. The Court sought to break down the figures indicated in the 1996 Annual Report on Fight against Fraud and establish whether or not they provide a true picture of the actual situation: in theory the figures presented as Member State formal communications are the total of the amounts transmitted by Member States under the various regulations governing the fields of Community revenue and expenditure and, with the exception of own resources, registered in the IRENE database (see paragraph 4.4 and Annex I, table 1).