SPECIAL REPORT No 8/98 on the Commission's services specifically involved in the fight against fraud, notably the 'unité de coordination de la lutte anti-fraude` (UCLAF) together with the Commission's replies (pursuant to Article 188c(4), second subparagraph, of the EC Treaty) (98/C 230/01)
INTRODUCTION
Scope of the audit
1.1. At the beginning of 1997 the Court decided to carry out an audit of the services of the Commission responsible for the fight against fraud, especially the 'Unité de Coordination de la Lutte Antifraude` (UCLAF). To date the audit work has covered an evaluation of the measures taken to establish appropriate legal, organisational and administrative arrangements to ensure the success of UCLAF's mission, an assessment of the effectiveness of UCLAF based on an examination of all its units, enquiries in the United Kingdom and the Netherlands (1) and a global examination of the anti-fraud responsibilities of the Security Office, DG XIX and DG XX.
Main observations
1.2. The Commission has, in particular since 1990, made a major effort in its fight against fraud. This has led to a better legal and administrative framework in this area (see paragraphs 2.4-2.6). However, Conventions and Protocols agreed under the third pillar have still not been ratified (see paragraph 2.11).
1.3. A structure within the Commission has been created for the fight against fraud (see paragraphs 2.20-2.23). However, the organisational arrangements, including those in relation to the Member States, are not always clear, and are often complicated and cumbersome (see paragraph 2.34, table 1, paragraphs 3.21-3.23 and 3.35-3.36). Furthermore, security measures and procedures are frequently not correctly implemented (see paragraphs 2.28-2.32).
1.4. UCLAF has been given more tasks, more powers and more staff. The number of temporary staff is about 50 % of total staff which creates a lack of continuity in the organisation (see paragraphs 3.2-3.4).
1.5. The databases of UCLAF were not fully operational or effective (see paragraphs 3.29-3.33). The databases were rarely used and the information kept by three of the four operational units within UCLAF did not reconcile with the database Pre-IRENE (see paragraphs 3.8-3.10).