, Special Report No 8/98 on the Commission's services specifically involved in the fight a…

In forcesince 10 Jun 1998

7.1. As this enquiry did not include the Member States and the Commission's operational DGs in great depth the findings concentrate on UCLAF. The Commission has, in particular since 1990, made a major effort in its fight against fraud relating to European funds which has resulted in a better legal and administrative framework for the fight against fraud. At the end of 1994 the Commission began setting up UCLAF as a central service with requisite financial, police, customs, judicial and tax expertise. However, improvements to security measures, the internal management procedures, intelligence and information systems and the cooperation with the responsible authorities of the Member States are of vital importance.

7.2. An overall evaluation of the results achieved by UCLAF up to now is difficult. However, the information on recoveries communicated by the Member States and included in the Annual Reports on Fight against Fraud is not reliable and does not differentiate between recoveries due to work of UCLAF and that of the national authorities. Furthermore in the area of direct expenditure no easily accessible information exists on the total amount to be recovered as a result of investigations effected by UCLAF. Finally the instruments 'black list` and 'fraud proofing` of legislation have only been introduced recently and have had a limited impact so far.

7.3. UCLAF needs a management system that holds information on the status of actual or former cases from the moment of receiving or obtaining the initial suspicion, to the administrative enquiry, seize of national authorities, penal investigation, prosecution, trial, decision and recovery. Without such a system an overall evaluation of its performance is virtually impossible.

7.4. The first steps have been taken in an ambitious programme to fight fraud simultaneously from all sides (prevention, enforcement and administrative and judicial cooperation). Important efforts still have to be made to put these initiatives fully into effect. None of the Conventions and Protocols agreed in the context of the third pillar has yet been ratified.

  • celex=31996R1355