, Special Report No 8/98 on the Commission's services specifically involved in the fight a…

In forcesince 10 Jun 1998

3.15. The files examined ranged from those that were well structured, indexed and annotated (in the minority), to those that were little more than a collection of documents placed in no particular order onto ring binders. The most common shortcomings noted were absences of clear identification of case documents on the files (no listing, frequently no date(s), no indication of the source and finally often no case summary). Where progress/mission reports were held on the file they were not of a uniform content and did not appear to have been drawn up within any particular time frame, i.e. a six monthly progress report, mission report completed within a certain time following the mission etc. Furthermore the case files rarely contained any evidence that reviews by the coordinators and/or the heads of units had been carried out. No record of resources employed and time spent on each case exists. In addition there is no referencing system to link related cases. One officer had inherited and/or opened six files on one and the same suspect.

3.16. In a comparison with the systematic way many national investigation services are forced to compile an investigation file for the prosecutor it is difficult to see how the UCLAF files can form the basis for a case respecting national laws. Disclosure of evidence, used and unused material etc. are only some of the requirements of national law the Commission will have to respect when making use of the new on-the-spot control Regulation (Euratom EC) No 2185/96 (see paragraphs 20-22 of Annex I).

3.17. The lack of overall guidelines as to the form and content of case files (or at the very least a set of minimum requirements) needs to be addressed. The increase in size of UCLAF from 10 staff in 1987 to 126 today, when combined with the increased case load means that more effective ways of managing staff and monitoring cases are required.

3.18. A consequence of the absence of file discipline is that it allows the possibility of the manipulation of the files by adding or removing documents at any time. This could reduce UCLAF's credibility and the value of the evidence produced if the defendant has good legal advisors.

Cooperation with the Member States

Constraints imposed on the Commission services