6.5. Although a number of such cases could be expected in an organisation of the size of the Commission, no standard procedure for handling such cases has been adopted. Despite the fact that some cases were several years old, procedures for investigating such cases were improvised on a case by case basis. No clear guidelines exist as to how the administrative investigations have to be carried out. Questions remain as to what the powers of the officials of UCLAF and the Security Office are in terms of searching of premises, sequestration of property and documents and questioning officials and what the rights and obligations of the persons suspected are. Furthermore, and perhaps more seriously, it is not clear at which stage national prosecuting authorities have to be notified and thus when the important change from the sphere of an administrative enquiry to a judicial investigation takes place (48).
6.6. The current situation gives rise to the serious and unacceptable risk that any investigation carried out will fail because the laws relating to investigation of such cases are not respected and any subsequent prosecution will therefore be rejected.
6.7. The rules related to collection of evidence and its subsequent use are markedly different in the various Member States. This is true, in particular, for the documents that a person, later accused during criminal proceedings, has been required to produce in a preliminary administrative investigation. The rules on the exclusion of evidence illegally obtained and as to the point at which a suspect becomes an accused person, and therefore starts to enjoy special rights (particularly the right to have charges communicated, the right to silence, the right to assistance by a defence lawyer of the accused's choice etc.) also vary from one Member State to another (49).
Implementation of a 'zero tolerance` policy
6.8. Many of the cases investigated by UCLAF have been initiated by members of staff of the Commission reporting their suspicions relating to other officials. In all types of organisation this has proved to be one of the main sources of information when the uncovering of corrupt practices is made (50). In order to foster the climate in which this type of information is forwarded and where fraudulent or corrupt practices are not tolerated the policy of the Commission must be clear and unambiguous.