6.11. At present the Commission's policy is anything but clear; cases are left to drag on for years with members of staff being transferred away from their post but remaining within the organisation (54). In many cases examined, UCLAF was not able to produce sufficient evidence for corruption. This could be due to the fact that the initial suspicion was not justified or that UCLAF was not able to uncover malpractice. In any case it is difficult for UCLAF to uncover sufficient evidence where payments were, for example, passed to third persons because no European institution has the power to search a house, analyse bank accounts etc. These actions can only be carried out with the agreement of the persons concerned or after authorisation by the competent judicial authorities. Nevertheless in all presumed corruption cases examined UCLAF was able to find clear evidence of breach of discipline (serious mismanagement, favouritism, conflict of interests etc.). However only in exceptional cases have disciplinary procedures been launched (55).
6.12. Cases occurred where an administrative enquiry took place (during the investigation or after the presentation of a final report by UCLAF) which was not covered by the staff regulation or any other legal text. In such cases the official charged with the ad hoc investigation (normally a director independent of the DG concerned) is likely to encounter problems (transcription of minutes of the hearings/interviews/auditions; presence of lawyers; search for/requisition of documents). Again there are no guidelines covering the conduct of such investigations.
6.13. Experience so far raises questions whether UCLAF as presently structured should be responsible for dealing with cases of corruption involving staff of the Commission. This responsibility could be incompatible with the partnership between the operational DGs and UCLAF which is necessary to make UCLAF's investigations successful. Consideration should be given to the establishment of a separate unit to which any suspicion of corruption would automatically be communicated, and which would have the authority and resources to undertake any necessary investigation.
CONCLUSION