, Special Report No 8/98 on the Commission's services specifically involved in the fight a…

In forcesince 10 Jun 1998

4.6. The own resources Decision and its implementation Council Regulation (EEC, Euratom) No 1552/89 require Member States to establish, enter in the accounts and recover any amounts due in cases where fraud or irregularity has been established (28). The Commission's role is to ensure that recovery procedures are indeed initiated and completed by national authorities so that Member States can be given a discharge when their management can be considered as satisfactory. If sums are not recoverable because of bankruptcy or lapse of time, the Member State has to show that it has done everything possible to recover them if it is to be exempted from making them available to the Community.

4.7. The main difficulty in ensuring effective financial monitoring is that two areas of competence are involved. There is, on the one hand, the entry of amounts in the accounts which is usually the responsibility of accounting services. On the other hand there is the investigation and reporting of fraud, which is normally dealt with by specific departments. Therefore data contained in IRENE cannot easily be reconciled with data kept in the Member States. This is in part because the separate B accounts do not solely identify amounts relating to fraud and irregularities, nor was this the intention of the separate accounts.

4.8. The Commission should monitor constantly the own resources recovery situation and thus be able to call for measures which it feels are necessary in order to make up inadequacies in national action. Furthermore due to the technical problems described in paragraph 4.4 IRENE as at September 1997 only contained information for 1996 and 1997 for seven and eight Member States respectively and there has not been a systematic updating of the data concerning the traditional own resources for nearly one year.

4.9. A further difficulty lies in the fact that up to July 1996 no obligation existed for the Member States to update regularly their reports and to systematically notify the Commission of amounts recovered. After the amendment of the Regulation a quarterly detailed updating of statements of recoveries sent in by Member States in cases of fraud or irregularity is now provided for.

EAGGF guarantee section

  • celex=31991R0595