, Special Report No 8/98 on the Commission's services specifically involved in the fight a…

In forcesince 10 Jun 1998

3.6. In addition to the staff and accommodation costs of UCLAF, the Commission's expenditure on the fight against fraud amounted to 11,1 Mio ECU in 1996 and (an estimated) 11,9 Mio ECU in 1997 (see Annex II).

3.7. The anti-fraud appropriations allocated exclusively to the Commission include appropriations relating to specific activities of UCLAF such as specialist computer programmes, access to databases, certain computers, etc. These are, in practice, charged to budget line A-3 5 3 0 and in some specific cases to A-3 5 3 1. The anti-fraud appropriations allocated for the direct benefit of the Member States are used by UCLAF to finance national control structures, to cover the use of experts in national investigations or joint investigations with the Commission, training expenditure, and to cofinance certain programmes for setting up new control methods.

Working methods

3.8. The operational work of UCLAF is governed primarily by the information that is received from the various sources available (see paragraph 3.28). It is assessed by the staff of UCLAF and a decision is taken whether or not to open a case in relation to the information received. The Court sought to document the system by which the cases are opened, monitored, reported and concluded. However, no common system exists and moves toward standardisation, notably through the internal management system Pre-IRENE (see Annex III), have had only limited success.

3.9. There was a clear difference between the units as regards utilisation of the Pre-IRENE computer system. This ranged from almost complete utilisation of the system to the minimal use of the computer tool to keep a simple, if incomplete, list of the cases related to the unit. A significant number of cases introduced were never updated using the system. The units that did not make full use of the Pre-IRENE internal management tool used a variety of methods to keep track of cases, including spreadsheets developed within the unit and meetings between investigators of the unit. These various listings and management tools could not be reconciled with each other as regards the number of cases.

3.10. Table 3 shows the number of cases held on the UCLAF Pre-IRENE database and those held on other forms of listings in the various operational units.

>TABLE>