the physical impossibility of admitting a second service supplier for baggage handling;
the negative consequences on the quality of services provided.
The exemption decision is based on the arguments and studies presented by FAG, which are annexed to the Decision, namely:
Netherlands Airport Consultants BV (NACO) study (I) Vorfeldverkehr of 10 December 1993,
NACO study (II) Vorfeldverkehr und Flughafenkapazität of 18 June 1994,
NACO study (III) Eine Zusätzliche Abfertigungsgesellschaft of 17 February 1995,
NACO study (IV) Eine Zusätzliche Abfertigungsgesellschaft, updated for the period 1997-2000, from 27 October 1995,
NACO study (IV), re-updated from 14 May 1997,
comments by NACO on the conclusions presented at the hearing of 9 July 1997 as part of the procedure referred to in paragraph 2.3 above, and sent by Germany to the Commission on 30 October 1997,
several letters from FAG to the Commission dated 25 July,
Fraunhofer-Institut für Materialfluß und Logistik (study I): Kapazitäts- und Qualitätsauswirkungen einer Zulassung zusätzlicher Abfertiger auf dem Vorfeld für den Flughafen Frankfurt/Main of 1 August 1994,
Fraunhofer-Institut für Materialfluß und Logistik (study II): Kapazitäts- und Qualitätsauswirkungen für den Flughafen Frankfurt/Main durch die Zulassung eines weiteren Abfertigers auf dem Vorfeld für die Jahre 1995/2000 of 16 February 1995.
The problems of space needed to store equipment
The exemption decision is based on the lack of space for parking the extra equipment of one or more users carrying out self-handling, or additional service suppliers, and the consequences of the work's being carried out at the airport.
1.1. The NACO and Fraunhofer studies
The NACO studies quantify the total space available at 148 000 m2, this figure being obtained by adding 102 000 m2 of parking areas, 22 000 m2 of preparation areas, 22 000 m2 of vehicle and equipment storage areas and 2 000 m2 of 'buffer zone`.
Of the 148 000 m2 available, FAG, which, since Delta abandoned self-handling at the beginning of 1997, is currently the only service supplier, currently occupies 146 000 m2 for its own groundhandling requirements (3): this estimate takes account of the fact that the airport currently provides all ramp handling services, thus including services provided for Delta and services provided for the companies which replaced Delta in Terminal 2 when Delta substantially reduced its flights in 1997.