On the basis of the various evaluations presented by NACO and Cranfield and taking into account the different hypotheses as to the distribution of clients and the periods of the day over which handling services can be spread out, it appears nevertheless that the following can be estimated:
that the need for space lies between 104 000 m2 and 165 000 m2;
that the available space can be estimated at between 148 000 m2 and 164 000 m2.
Even on the most pessimistic assumption used by NACO (need for 165 000 m2 for an available space of 148 000 m2), the available space would allow for parking of 90 % of all required equipment. However, in an airport where peak hours are very limited, as FAG itself agrees, at least 10 % of the equipment is not parked but remains in constant circulation. Outside the peak hours this equipment can then be parked on spaces which have remained vacant.
Use of the space available
As was indicated above, Article 9 must be interpreted in a restrictive manner, taking into account the aim of the measure. As is shown by its title, the aim of the Directive is to provide access to the groundhandling market and the principle of free access is clearly defined in Articles 6 and 7 even though it is true that specific possibilities are granted to the Member States to limit access to a minimum of two operators for certain categories of service.
The Commission is of the opinion that adherence to the aim of the Directive means that only the constraints mentioned in Article 9, which by themselves present obstacles to the implementation of the Directive, can afford a basis for exemption. This cannot include constraints created by the airport itself, as was the case for the allocation of space left vacant by Delta even after the adoption of the Directive. The impossibility of opening up the market must be ascribable to a factor which is independent of the will of the party relying on it.
For a number of years, new space has been vacant at the airport. However, the development plans for the airport show that the space freed has always been, and still is, allocated to uses other than groundhandling, including commercial activities not essential to air traffic management.
It is not lack of space as such which makes it impossible to admit any new operator at Frankfurt but principally the use which FAG has decided to make of the space available or which will become available which could create problems if another operator were admitted.