It is recognised that admission of one or more operators requires extra space: equipment requirements are geared to the volume of traffic at the airport's peak time. In a monopoly situation, the peak time at the airport is, therefore, the reference point. In the event of competition, however, the peak time of each operator is the point which must be taken into account; this does not always coincide with the peak for the airport in general. As a result, total equipment requirements at the airport depend on the sum total of the peak requirements of each supplier. Competition therefore increases total requirements in terms of equipment, and hence of parking space for it.
However, another factor which must be taken into account is that any opening-up to competition will reduce the market share of the previous monopoly-holder, thus reducing that operator's equipment and, hence, space requirements. Allowance must be made for such repercussions, even though requirements will not necessarily fall in proportion to market share, so that it is difficult to assess the impact of opening up to competition on each supplier's market share, which will depend not only on each supplier's market share but also on the relevant customer distribution.
2.1. Space available at Frankfurt
The studies commissioned by FAG put the total space available at 148 000 m2, of which FAG itself currently occupies 146 000 m2. These figures are for the current situation at Frankfurt, whereby FAG services all flights, including the few flights still operated by Delta at the airport in 1997. The current situation is, therefore, that there are no major space problems at Frankfurt airport. According to FAG, the arrival of a new supplier would create a space shortage of 32 000 m2.
The NACO studies indicate that on the assumption that Delta performed its own handling services and operated more flights, the forecast for 1997 would have resulted in a space shortage of 13 725 m2. Allowing for the traffic growth forecast and planned at the airport, this shortfall would have risen to 16 300 m2 by 2000. FAG estimates that in the same scenario admission of a second supplier would have pushed the space shortage up to 32 200 m2 in 1997 and to over 35 000 m2 in 2000.
The Commission has a number of comments to make on these studies:
Estimates