, Decision_act (EU) 1998/387

In forcesince 14 Jan 1998

However, the net additional space requirements attributable by NACO to Delta (13 778 m2) should not be counted together with the net additional space requirements attributable to the additional handler, because they are not due to the presence of the independent handler but to that of Delta and because in any case Delta has ceased self-handling and the requirements attributable to the handling of Delta flights are already included in the 146 000 m2 required by FAG. The net additional space requirements of an independent handler as compared with the monopoly conditions should accordingly be some 18 500 m2 (32 000 minus 13 725). In the present situation where FAG is the only operator since Delta has ceased its activities, one would accordingly expect the total space requirements attributable to be less than 165 000 m2 (146 000 plus 18 500) and not the NACO figure of 178 000 m2.

Moreover, in the scenario adopted by NACO, Delta was not only operating more flights than in 1997, but was also using equipment with capacity to handle more flights than it was operating at the time. In fact, Delta managed to park on an area of 8 000 m2 equipment capable of ensuring the major part of the handling of 8 to 10 % of flights at the airport.

This fact shows clearly that far less space is needed to service this segment of the market than is estimated in the NACO studies. This is even more true in view of the fact that Delta used a share of the market comparable to the figure used in the NACO study and that Delta, which does not operate in the afternoon, needed the space to park all of its equipment, which would not be the case for a supplier operating for several clients and would therefore be able to spread its services in a more regular way across the whole day.

In addition, NACO's estimate is based on each supplier's peak requirements (see above) but simply adds together all the space required by each supplier in order to park all its equipment, disregarding the fact that a large proportion of the equipment is in use virtually non-stop and is not parked for most of the day, least of all in such a busy airport as Frankfurt. The equipment is parked at night, when there are no flights to service, and it can therefore be parked in the positions available, as it is today.

In fact, the need for space in connection with access to the market depends to a large extent on the distribution of clients between the suppliers and the spreading of operations over the whole day.