, Decision_act (EU) 1998/387

In forcesince 14 Jan 1998

Although the decision to increase capacity is one which may not be limited exclusively to the commercial interest of the airport alone, but is of wider economic importance, nonetheless the Directive is meant to be applied by airports, exemptions being granted only where it is impossible to open up the market. The temporary nature of the exemption would, on its own, be sufficient reason to open up the market, if any were needed. Were it otherwise, then airports would acquire the right to decide for themselves, as long as they see fit, which objectives that they consider to take priority over application of the legislation. Moreover, the German authorities' argument could be supported by all airports, though possibly to differing degrees, since any extra space made available to groundhandling operations must be taken away from the space which could be allocated for other purposes. The problem addressed by the Directive is different: it is to determine whether space or capacity problems 'exist` for the purposes of Article 9(4) of the Directive which make it impossible to open up the market, and not whether hopes or decisions to develop capacity for economic reasons may be fulfilled. The German authorities have provided no proof that it is impossible.

As was mentioned earlier, the total number of positions planned (156) should meet the demand generated by the increase in runway capacity.

Finally, Germany bases the exemption decision on the effects of opening up the market on management of the system and baggage sorting operations and on the quality of service at Frankfurt, notably the minimum connecting time. Article 9 of the Directive allows exemptions to be granted on the basis of space and capacity constraints only. The Commission cannot, therefore, accept this argument.

3.

Measures planned

Under Article 9(2) of the Directive, any decision to grant an exemption must be accompanied by a plan of appropriate measures to overcome the alleged constraints.

Germany explains its exemption decision by reference to a space and congestion problem at the airport. The space problem has not been demonstrated and the congestion is, in the view of the Commission, confined to Terminal 1. However, no plan to totally overcome this congestion problem accompanied the German authorities' decision.

The final reason given for the exemption is exacerbation of the congestion at Terminal 1.