However, the configuration of a terminal cannot in itself be an adequate reason for maintaining a monopoly. By limiting exemptions granted by Member States under Article 9(1)(b) to a maximum of two years, which may be extended once only, and by stipulating that users must have an effective choice whatever part of the airport is allocated to them, the Directive does not allow Member States to deprive users of this right by way of constraints if there are no plans to change them throughout the period covered by the exemption. All exemptions must be accompanied by measures to overcome the constraints invoked as reasons for granting them.
The exemption submitted made no provision for any reconfiguration of Terminal 1 to overcome the constraints invoked. Consequently, the configuration by itself cannot justify extension of the monopoly beyond the date set in Article 1 of the Directive for opening up the market at airports in the same category as Frankfurt, namely beyond 1 January 1999.
2.4. Ongoing work
The exemption is based on the fact that construction work is in progress on Pier A in Terminal 1 to create new aircraft gates and to reduce the airport's dependence on remote positions on the western part of the tarmac. In addition, the whole of Terminal 1 is being converted to comply with the Schengen standards, particularly by doubling the floors in Terminal 1. Terminal 2 already complies with these standards. This work should be completed by the end of 2000. This extension should increase the number of gate parking positions and reduce the distance to certain remote positions, thereby reducing boarding and disembarkation times and traffic in the area.
While this work is in progress the exacerbation of problems caused by an already difficult ground-traffic situation in the northern part of Pier A and in both culs-de-sac will preclude the parallel presence of any additional operator at Terminal 1, up to Gate C 15 of Pier C, according to the 1994 plan dated 16 May 1994 submitted by the German authorities. This limitation to a single operator must therefore, for the same reason, cover not only operations on the apron between piers but also operations involving the transport of passengers, baggage and crew as well as freight and mail between aircraft on remote positions and Terminal 1. This work, making it impossible to open up the market, combined with the exceptional but temporary nature of its consequences could be reasons for granting an exemption.