, Decision_act (EU) 1998/387

In forcesince 14 Jan 1998

The German decision allows the situation which existed prior to the entry into force of the Directive to continue. It restricts the number of parties involved even more than is intended by the Directive, as it prohibits self-handling and reserves to the airport alone the right to provide groundhandling services to third parties. It covers self-handling and handling for third parties of the following services set out in the Annex to the Directive: baggage handling (point 3), certain ramp-handling services - loading and unloading of aircraft (point 5.4) and the operation of appropriate units for engine-starting (point 5.5), the moving of aircraft (point 5.6), and freight and mail handling as described in Articles 6(2) and 7(2) (point 4). The German authorities' decision would therefore open the market up to the extent provided for in the Directive, namely to at least a second service-supplier and to two self-handling airport users, only in respect of a limited range of ramp-handling services - services relating to aircraft marshalling, parking, communication between the aircraft and the supplier of services, and the transport and loading of food and beverages and - for freight and post services - customs and administrative formalities. There is to be a completely free market for cleaning services.

2.3. Article 86 of the Treaty

On 20 July 1993 the companies KLM Royal Dutch Airlines NV, Air France Compagnie Nationale SA, and British Airways plc lodged a complaint with the Commission about the performance of groundhandling services at Frankfurt airport, suggesting that the company Flughafen Frankfurt/Main AG (FAG) had infringed Article 86 of the Treaty.

The various studies and comments on this matter have been communicated by the German authorities in support of the exemption decision, including the comments of FAG on the study carried out by Cranfield University for the Commission.

II.

CONSTRAINTS PLEADED BY GERMANY

The exemption granted by the German Government is based principally on the problems of the space available at the airport:

(a)

the impossibility for the airport of finding the space needed to store additional groundhandling equipment;

(b)

the exacerbation of these space problems as a result of the works currently being carried out at the airport.

Furthermore, the following implications of opening up the market as envisaged in the Directive were cited:

(a)

the resulting reduction in capacity, particularly airside;