The main purpose of the Directive is to liberalise groundhandling services. Limitations imposed on third parties amount to restrictions of those parties' freedom to provide services. By way of analogy with State measures restricting the freedom to provide services, and as the Court of Justice has held in its judgments of 25 July 1991 in Case C-288/89, Mediawet (4) and Case C-76/90, Säger v. Dennemeyer (5), measures which are liable to exclude or prohibit the activities of a provider of services even if they apply without distinction to national providers of services and to those of other Member States, must be justified by overriding reasons relating to a non-economic public interest and must in addition be proportionate to the objective they pursue.
1.2. Procedure
Under Article 9(6), the exemptions relating to self-handling granted under Article 9(1)(d) may not exceed a duration of three years and may be renewed, while those relating to service suppliers granted under Article 9(1)(b) may not exceed a duration of two years, which may be extended only for a single period of two years.
In accordance with Article 9(3) of the Directive, the German authorities undertook to make the entry into force of the exemption decision subject to a Commission decision approving it.
In accordance with the procedure provided for in Article 9(3), (4) and (5), the Commission must examine the exemption granted by the Member State and approve that decision or oppose it. It may also require the Member State to amend the extent of the exemption or restrict it to those parts of the airport where the alleged constraints have been proved to exist.
The Commission therefore considers that in its examination it must concentrate on the following three points:
the existence and extent of the space and capacity constraints used to justify the exemption and the impossibility of opening up the market to the degree provided for in the Directive;