At Terminal l, by contrast, an increase in the number of operators would make groundhandling equipment traffic extremely difficult. The configuration of Terminal 1 already poses problems with aircraft shunting in the culs-de-sac between Piers A and B, and between Piers B and C. The presence of several handlers and/or self-handling users would cause problems. A number of handlers is likely to occur in the eastern part of the Terminal where several airlines operate. The western part, by contrast, has been allocated to Lufthansa and Condor on an almost exclusive basis. According to the flight plan simulation submitted by FAG (Fraunhofer 27 June 1997, last Annex), 94 % of the movements in that area are attributable to Lufthansa and Condor, while other airlines account for 124 weekly movements only (approximately one movement every three days on each stand of this area). Conversely, Lufthansa or Condor flights outside this area are very limited, with the exception of position B2 which is almost fully allocated to Lufthansa. This implies that in this area predominantly one handler would operate in any case (be it FAG, an independent handler or Lufthansa as a self-handler). Accordingly there are no technical obstacles to Lufthansa's being handled by a different handler than the one operating in the eastern part of Terminal 1.
On 7 January 1998, FAG indicated a change in those figures, stating that in August 1997 an average of 12,2 % of the traffic in the western part of Terminal 1 accounted for 18 airlines other than Lufthansa. The Commission is not convinced that, even on the assumption of those figures being true and representative, such an increase would necessarily result in severe congestion problems. Moreover, it should be noted that FAG is responsible for the allocation of airlines to their different stands and, where the congestion problems increase, can take measures to reduce the problem. In this context, it should be recalled that only the constraints recited in Article 9 of the Directive can serve as a basis for an exemption. The impossibility of opening up the market must be due to a factor which is independent from the will of the party bringing it up.