Recital 17, Decision_act (EU) 1994/985

In forcesince 21 Dec 1994

The choice between merchant haulage and carrier haulage is left open to shippers. This was described in the following terms in the expert report prepared for the FEFC and presented to the Commission during the course of the administrative proceedings in this case (1).

'4.41. Optionality: Although carrier haulage is often the preferred option, the availability of merchant haulage has a number of very important aspects, many of which go back to the early days of containerization.

4.42. First, when the conferences first offered through-transport services in the late 1960's and early 1970's, they still carried the vast majority of liner cargoes on their respective routes and were in a dominant position. It was important that shippers did not consider that they were being asked to support services which abused this position. In addition, where the conferences moved into new commercial fields, such as inland transport, it was important that the service was offered under conditions which would attract customers and expand the idea of integrated distribution services. This included the offer of reasonable rates for carrier haulage. But this was not enough, and it was important that shippers should retain the option to carry on as before and continue to arrange their own merchant haulage if they so wished.

4.43. A second important point concerns foreign exchange costs. All importers of goods incur foreign exchange costs when buying abroad, and this includes sea freight costs. However, under the conventional system local inland transport costs were paid for in the national currency. Traders and national governments could reasonably have been expected to object to a system which, as a result of incorporation of local movements into a unified tariff system, inland costs would be transferred into a foreign currency. A separate inland tariff allows import legs to be invoiced separately and to be paid in local currency, without disturbing the physical and commercial through-transport attributes of the through journey and through bill of lading.

4.44. A third aspect concerns the position of fob buyers. Some importers, usually very large and powerful ones, choose to nominate their own ocean carriers, usually national lines of their own country. In choosing the carrier on the sea leg of a through journey, they influence the inland leg in their own country. They are not usually interested in how the exporter moves the goods to the port of exit in the exporting country, leaving it to him to determine whether to do it himself by merchant haulage or to arrange for the through-transport operator to do it by carrier haulage. Fob buying is neutral with respect to the choice between carrier or merchant haulage at either end of the route, but separate inland tariffs are necessary to make available this option.'