The fact that ICI for some time apparently attempted to conceal from Solvay the full extent of its production difficulties in the United Kingdom does not, as ICI argues, disprove the existence of any collusive arrangement between them. The understanding between them as to their respective spheres of influence in the United Kingdom and continental western Europe respectively was not the result of any altruism on Solvay's part but depended upon a complex interplay of interests. In the event of any perceived long-term inability on the part of ICI to balance production with United Kingdom demand, Solvay could hardly be expected to stand by while other west European producers took advantage. The whole object of the arrangement was the maintenance of the status quo in the interests of the two producers. Given also that any collusive agreement would be unenforceable and would only be respected so long as it was in both parties' interests, ICI may well have been prudent not to trust Solvay entirely on this occasion.
Similarly, the possibility of 'retaliation` which Solvay and ICI claim as the reason for their respective abstention from each other's 'home market` in no way excludes the existence of any understanding between them. On the contrary, it was generally accepted by the industry that 'retaliation` was the normal sanction for any breach of the 'home market` principle: the threat of retaliation thus served to encourage continued cooperation.
In summary, the documentation obtained from the producers shows that far from considering themselves as business rivals Solvay and ICI saw each other as close partners.